HOME | ADS | ALLEYS | CEMETERIES | COBBLESTONES | FORGOTTENSLICES | LAMPS | NEIGHBORHOODS | SIGNS | STREET NECROLOGY | STREET SCENES | SUBWAYS & TRAINS | TROLLEYS | YOU'D NEVER BELIEVE YOU'RE IN NYC | LINKS | FORGOTTENTOURS | FORGOTTENSTUFF | QUEENS CRAP | FRANK JUMP'S FADING ADS | OUT OF TOWN | BOWERY BOYS | ALL CITY NY | LOST CITY | VANISHING NY | LONG ISLAND ODDITIES | GOTHAM LOST AND FOUND | NEWTOWN HISTORICAL SOCIETY | GREATER ASTORIA HISTORICAL SOCIETY | NY400 | FNY THE BOOK/ERRATA | CONDENSED POP | SEARCH

FORGOTTEN NEW YORK
HarperCollins,
ORDER from Amazon: paperback or hardcover

A small traffic triangle in front of the clock-towered Bank of Manhattan, where Northern Boulevard begins its march to the eastern end of Long Island, contains two of the oldest man-made objects in Queens embedded in its concrete.

In 1650, Dutchman Burger Jorissen constructed a grist mill that today would be on Northern Boulevard between 40th Road and 41st Avenue. The mill existed on the site for about 111 years, until 1861 when it was razed by the Long Island Rail Road. The Payntar family by that time owned the mill property (40th Avenue was called Payntar Avenue until the 1920s) and had placed millstones that had been shipped in by Jorissen around 1657 in front of their house. The Payntar house was razed in the early 1900s. When Sunnyside Yards, Queens Plaza and the Bank of Manhattan and the elevated were constructed, the millstones were fortunately preserved and embedded in the traffic plaza.

Payntar House east of Northern Blvd about 1900. Millstones were moved to sidewalk in front of house between ca 1860 and ca 1912).

Head of Dutch Kills looking north from Queens Blvd. (black arrow is Payntar house and blue arrow is Sunnyside)

LEFT: Belcher Hyde map showing milldam along former Skillman Avenue. (black arrow Payntar House, purple arrows old road to Queens Plaza)

Queens Plaza, 2009. Orange arrows show millstone location ca 1920 to 2009. White arrow: site of former Long Island Savings Bank

Original location of millstones. (blue arrow Sunnyside and black arrow Payntar house)

The millstones, as they appeared in 2009 until reconstruction began on the triangular traffic plaza in front of the Bank of Manhattan building. Both had suffered deterioration in recent years (see title card above for a view from some decades ago).

FNY Queens Plaza page, showing the now-razed parking garage and Long Island Savings Bank buildings
Left, above: Bob Singleton and Richard Melnick of the Greater Astoria Historical Society peek through construction fence to inspect one of the millstones. Photos: NY Daily News
The traffic island where the millstones are embedded has been converted into a staging area for heavy construction equipment. Historians fear for the condition of the millstones, already compromised by years of wear and tear. One of the stones has been removed from the plaza and crated, while the other remains in place. A representative from the city Economic Development Corp, which is reconstructing the plaza, maintains that the stones will eventually be displayed in a 1.5 acre green space at the northeast end of Queens Plaza. But can they survive the manhandling they are receiving now?

The GAHS is sponsoring a community discussion on the millstones' fate on November 18th, 2009 at 6:30 PM at the Quinn Building, 35-20 Broadway, Long Island City.

The organization suggests:

Making the millstones available to our community by moving them from a construction site to an exhibit space at the Greater Astoria Historical Society, where they will be safe and secure and on display; accessible to everyone with an exhibit outlining their history.

Making the millstones available to historians and scholars to conduct research (during the period while they are out of the ground), and to support efforts to make them official New York City Designated Landmarks.

HOME | ADS | ALLEYS | CEMETERIES | COBBLESTONES | FORGOTTENSLICES | LAMPS | NEIGHBORHOODS | SIGNS | STREET NECROLOGY | STREET SCENES | SUBWAYS & TRAINS | TROLLEYS | YOU'D NEVER BELIEVE YOU'RE IN NYC | LINKS | FORGOTTENTOURS | FORGOTTENSTUFF | QUEENS CRAP | FRANK JUMP'S FADING ADS | OUT OF TOWN | BOWERY BOYS | ALL CITY NY | LOST CITY | VANISHING NY | LONG ISLAND ODDITIES | GOTHAM LOST AND FOUND | NEWTOWN HISTORICAL SOCIETY | GREATER ASTORIA HISTORICAL SOCIETY | NY400 | FNY THE BOOK/ERRATA | CONDENSED POP | SEARCH

Page completed November 13.

erpietri@earthlink.net

©2009